Family planning: Large family and poverty
No human being can be certain about his future or his fortune. Why, then,
do we go on producing many children, mainly females, who are the worst sufferers in this
life as they are subjugated and dominated by men. Would you also explain to me why 90
percent of people live in abject poverty and misery?
I do not think that you should address some question about the number of children a family
may have to a person like myself. You should address it to every married couple and let
them tell you why they have eight or ten or even more children. It is for a married couple
who can take measures to determine the number of children they may have. If they have
proper information, a married couple may realize that too frequent pregnancies and
childbirths may have adverse effects on the health of the mother and child as well as the
upbringing of the children. It certainly has its advantages, because the children can grow
up with a keen sense of cooperation and mutual care and love. On the other hand, the means
of the family may not be sufficient to give them a sound education.
The parents may, as a result, be too keen to get their sons to start work before they have
completed their education and to get their daughters married at an early age, in order to
reduce the family burden. The disadvantages are numerous indeed. But this is an individual
choice, particularly in this day and age when safe methods of birth control are available
to all and sundry.
I am intrigued by the emphasis you place on producing daughters, rather than sons. If all
families stop producing daughters, [as though they can choose the sex they want] human
life will some day come to a halt. The balance between girls and boys in society is
controlled by God at a particular level which ensures the continuity of human life and a
proper balance between males and females. However, your emphasis seems to have a rather
social slant.
You speak of the domination and subjugation of women by their men folk. While this is
sadly true in many societies, it is not always the case. Islam provides for the equal
treatment of boys and girls, men and women. It is true that in practice this may not be
properly maintained, but this is the fault of people, rather than the fault of the system
God has devised for human life. We often assume that men are superior to women, but Islam
says otherwise.
The fact that Islam has placed the same duties regarding beliefs, acts of worship, the
propagation of Islamic faith, and family responsibilities, is a clear indication that in
God's view, men and women are equal. God tells all His servants: "I shall not let the
actions of anyone of you, male or female, come to waste." (3;195) The Prophet says:
"Women are the sisters of men". This statement indicates complete equality if it
is translated in this form. However, the term the Prophet uses in Arabic to indicate
"sisters" has some special connotations. So it would probably be more accurate
to translate the Hadith as: "Women are the counterfoils of men." As you are
probably aware, counterfoils are meant to perfectly match each other. The Hadith makes
this equality between men and women at the most perfect level.
You do not want a reply on the lines that God provides for all His creatures. But the fact
is that He does. He says in the Qur'an: "There is no living creature which walks on
the face of the earth (or inside it) without having its provisions apportioned by
God" (11;6). But human beings have to work in order to get what God has provided for
them. They cannot just sit idle and expect that their provisions will come to them without
work.
We have to remember that God set in operation certain laws of nature which influence the
lives of human beings on earth. For example, He has made the availability of water in any
land area essential for the growth of vegetation. A piece of land without very little
rainfall and no other source of water will remain barren. We can see in this how the law
of cause and effect operates. In human life, if you do not work, you cannot earn your
living. When the Prophet was told of a man spending more of his time in voluntary worship,
he asked who fed him. Upon learning that the man's brother provided him with food and
drink, the Prophet commented that his brother was a better Muslim than him.
When we work, we rely on God to make our efforts successful. This is the proper type of
reliance. If we were to sit idle and claim that we rely on God for our maintenance, we are
guilty of a negative attitude which will only bring adverse results. It may be suggested
that a person is willing to work, but he cannot find a job. Some readers may also point
out that there are those who have enormous wealth and they care little for those who are
deprived. All this is true.
There is much social injustice in the great majority of human societies. But this is all
of man's own making. God has provided for us a system which ensures that no one should go
hungry and no one reaches the point of starvation. But even in Muslim countries, little
attention is paid to this system. Instead, we import alien ideas which may seek to achieve
social justice, but all they can do is to replace one form of social injustice with
another. We find maldistribution of wealth everywhere. I can tell you plainly that
wherever you find a small minority controlling wealth and the great majority living in
poverty, then you know that the system God has laid down is not [being] implemented.
God tells us in the Qur'an that He has created the earth and made it able to support all
living creatures for whom it is a dwelling place. Yet, you often find that resources are
not properly tapped, and if they are, the outcome is unfairly distributed. Both are
failings of human beings. If we want to achieve a decent living for all human beings, the
only way is to implement Islam properly, vigorously and fairly. We must not implement one
aspect of Islam and forget another. We have to implement it all and to seek to please God
in our efforts. If we do, we are certain to experience the sort of achievement that early
Muslim generations enjoyed, when zakah funds were carried on large trays in the market
place, and people were invited to take what they wanted, but none felt the need to do so,
because they were all enjoying a decent standard of living.
God has promised this repeatedly in the Qur'an, quoting one prophet after another who told
their nations: "Seek God's forgiveness and repent of your sins and He will send you
rain in torrent and give you strength in addition to what power you already have."
God's promise never fails.
Family planning: Surgical contraception
I have four children and I am considering resorting to a sterilization
operation to be done for my wife. She is thin and weak and can hardly cope with the
demands of the family, especially during my prolonged absence, away from home to work here
in Saudi Arabia. May I also say that my financial situation is not that bright. Indeed, I
can hardly cope with the great demands placed on me.
Let me first of all deal with the financial aspect of this question. We know that
Allah provides sustenance for everyone of His creation. I personally have experienced an
improvement in my financial situation with every child I have had. Indeed, that
improvement was very tangible in the case of one of my children. Some people may not have
such a tangible experience. It is true to say, however, that Allah will not neglect to
provide sustenance for any human being. It is up to the breadwinner of the family to make
use of the opportunities that Allah provides for him.
Having said that, I should also point out before attending to the question on
sterilization that resorting to methods of contraception which are safe and do not affect
the health of the mother is permissible. That must be kept at the individual level. By
this I mean that a family may resort to contraception in order to limit the number of
their children if they determine that such a thing is desirable in their particular
circumstances. At the time of the Prophet, peace be upon him, some of his companions
resorted to coitus interruptus, which was the only method of family planning known to
them, and the Prophet, peace be upon him, was aware of what they did. He did not instruct
them to stop, nor did he tell them that what they did was forbidden. Therefore, it is
permissible. Other methods of family planning have the same verdict provided they are
safe.
Sterilization which involves a surgical operation is a special case. Unlike other methods
of contraception it is permanent. Therefore it has to be viewed separately. Preventing
pregnancy by surgery is known as sterilization which can be performed for either the
husband or the wife. It is perhaps more accurate to say that we cannot make a general,
sweeping statement in order to say that such an operation is either forbidden or
permissible. Any surgery may be considered, from the strictly religious point of view, as
required, recommended or discouraged or forbidden, according to different circumstances of
its person.
If a highly competent doctor advises his patient that a certain operation will not only
cure his illness but also prevent a speedy deterioration of his case which is otherwise
inevitable, then he may be required to undertake that operation. If his case is tolerable
and no deterioration is likely in the absence of an operation, but the operation will
certainly improve his health, then we can say that the operation is recommended. On the
other hand, if there are no strong medical grounds for operating on a certain patient, but
the doctor advises operation only to get his fee, then the doctor commits a sin by giving
such an advice.
In the case of sterilization, what we have to look for is the effect of pregnancy on the
health of the mother. If a competent doctor determines that every pregnancy is likely to
pose a real threat to the life of the mother or to cause serious threat to her health and
that other methods of contraception may also have a bad effect on her health, then the
woman may have such an operation without the qualm of conscience. It is permissible in her
case. On the other hand, for a woman who asks her doctor to perform such an operation
because she feels that a pregnancy may spoil her figure or having children may stop her
from taking a long holiday every few months, such an operation is forbidden.
In your particular condition, I do not think the reasons you have advanced for such an
operation constitute a sound argument to justify the operation. Your wife may be thin and
weak, but you can easily delay pregnancy by resorting to other methods of contraception.
On the basis of what you say in your letter, you are only with your wife for a month or so
every year. If you take adequate precautions, you can almost certainly prevent pregnancy.
Therefore, the operation is not required on medical grounds. Hence, it cannot be lawful in
your case.
Fardh: Basic definition of
That is fardh which Allah has made obligatory for everyone of us, such as prayers,
fasting, zakah and pilgrimage. Reward is earned by fulfilling a fardh and punishment is
incurred by omitting it.
| Back | Contents | Next |